H.H. Holmes and the Murder Castle: The Real Story | Murder Apparel
Quick Answer
Who was H.H. Holmes? H.H. Holmes, born Herman Webster Mudgett in 1861, was an American con artist and killer who built a mixed-use building in Chicago during the 1893 World's Fair. Newspapers later called it the "Murder Castle" and filled it with invented torture chambers and trapdoors. The building was mostly an unfinished hotel above a drugstore. Holmes confessed to 27 murders, but historians confirm roughly nine. He was hanged in Philadelphia on May 7, 1896.
His real name was Herman Mudgett. He changed it because Herman Mudgett sounds like someone who fixes boilers, and H.H. Holmes sounds like a doctor, which is what he needed people to believe he was. He had attended the University of Michigan medical school. He financed his education there by stealing cadavers from the laboratory, disfiguring the bodies, planting them to look like accident victims, and collecting the insurance money. He graduated in 1884. He had the whole system worked out before he ever built anything in Chicago.
The building
In 1887, Holmes moved to Chicago and talked his way into managing a drugstore on 63rd Street in the Englewood neighborhood. The owner, a widow named Elizabeth Holton, eventually disappeared. Holmes took over the property. He bought the lot across the street and started construction on a three-story building: storefronts on the ground floor, office rentals on the second, hotel rooms on the third.
He fired contractors constantly. He'd hire a crew, refuse to pay them, have them thrown off the site for shoddy work, and hire the next one. No single contractor ever saw the whole building. Holmes later claimed this was intentional. That part is probably true. The building had gas lines running into some of the upper rooms. It had a large basement with a kiln. It was largely unfinished when it opened, because Holmes kept running out of money and creditors kept coming to the door, and he kept talking his way out of both problems.
After his arrest in 1894, Chicago newspapers began running stories about the building. Trap doors. Secret passages. A hundred locked rooms. Soundproofed chambers. A basement crematorium where the bones of hundreds of victims had been incinerated. Reporters competed with each other to produce the most elaborate version of the story. Historians who have examined the actual building records say most of it was invented. The gas lines were real. The kiln was real. The elaborate death architecture was a newspaper story.
How he actually killed people
Holmes was a con man who killed people as part of his cons. His primary method was engagement. He found women with money, became engaged to them, got control of their finances, took out life insurance policies on them, and killed them. He used chloroform. He used gas. He used a sealed vault in the building's basement. He was not particular about method.
He also killed men he'd brought in as business partners when they became inconvenient. Benjamin Pitezel was one of them. Holmes had recruited Pitezel as a general accomplice: they ran insurance schemes together, forged documents, sold fraudulent patents. Holmes eventually murdered Pitezel as part of an insurance scam, then took custody of three of Pitezel's children from his wife under the pretense of reuniting the family. He killed all three of them in separate cities over the following months while Pitezel's wife followed behind, a week behind, wondering where her children were.
The confession
Holmes confessed in 1895, while awaiting execution. He confessed to 27 murders. He named names. He described methods. He was paid $7,500 by the Hearst newspaper syndicate for the document. Several of the people he claimed to have murdered were found to be alive and well. Adam Selzer, the historian who has done the most recent and rigorous accounting of the case, puts the confirmed and probable victim count at nine. The number 27 is what Holmes told a newspaper. Holmes was a liar by profession.
He did sell skeletons. That part is confirmed. Bodies he could not dispose of otherwise were stripped, articulated, and sold to medical schools and doctors' offices. He knew the market from his time in Michigan. He knew what a prepared skeleton was worth and where to sell one without questions.
How he was caught
Not for murder. For insurance fraud. A postal inspector named Frank Geyer began tracking Holmes in 1894 after the Pitezel insurance claim raised flags. Geyer followed the trail of the missing Pitezel children across six states, finding their bodies in Toronto and Indianapolis. Holmes was arrested in Boston. He was extradited to Philadelphia, tried for Pitezel's murder, convicted, and sentenced to death.
He was hanged on May 7, 1896. The hanging was badly done. His neck did not break cleanly and he took roughly fifteen minutes to die. His one request before the execution was specific: he wanted to be buried ten feet deep in cement, inside a double-thickness coffin. He was afraid of grave robbers. He knew exactly what happened to bodies that weren't protected, because he had spent years doing it himself.
The building at 63rd and Wallace burned down a year after his arrest under circumstances that were never explained. A post office was eventually built on the site. People still report odd things in the basement.
If your relationship with history runs toward the part they leave out of textbooks, The Horrors Persist shirt is for you. The full horror collection covers the rest. And if H.H. Holmes is what got you into true crime in the first place, the post on why we can't stop consuming it is worth reading.
Murder Apparel is an independent, husband-and-wife brand making spooky, political gear for people who give a damn. We donate to fight injustice and support communities in need. 500,000+ weirdos on Instagram. Come find your people.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many people did H.H. Holmes kill?
Holmes confessed to 27 murders in 1895, but several of the people he named were found to be alive. Historian Adam Selzer, who has done the most rigorous modern accounting of the case, puts the confirmed and probable victim count at approximately nine. The number varies by source because Holmes was a compulsive liar and his confession was purchased by a newspaper syndicate for $7,500. The true count is unknown.
Was the Murder Castle real?
The building was real. The "Murder Castle" narrative, with its elaborate trap doors, secret passages, and hundred locked rooms, was largely invented by Chicago newspapers after Holmes's arrest in 1894. Historians who examined the actual building records found a largely unfinished three-story structure: storefronts on the ground floor, hotel rooms above, with gas lines in some rooms and a kiln in the basement. Holmes did use the building to kill people. The theatrical torture-chamber version came from competitive yellow press journalism.
How was H.H. Holmes caught?
Holmes was caught not for murder but for insurance fraud. Postal inspector Frank Geyer began investigating a suspicious life insurance claim involving Holmes's accomplice Benjamin Pitezel and tracked the disappearance of Pitezel's three children across six states. The children's bodies were found in Toronto and Indianapolis. Holmes was arrested in Boston in 1894 and extradited to Philadelphia, where he was tried and convicted of Pitezel's murder.
Why did H.H. Holmes ask to be buried in cement?
Holmes requested that his body be buried ten feet deep inside a double-thickness coffin encased in cement. He had spent years stripping bodies and selling skeletons to medical schools and was reportedly afraid of grave robbers doing the same to him. The request was granted.
Was H.H. Holmes really America's first serial killer?
Holmes is often called America's first serial killer, but the label is contested. Serial murder almost certainly predates Holmes. He is more accurately described as one of the first killers to receive mass media coverage that shaped the modern public understanding of serial murder. The "Murder Castle" coverage in 1895 established many of the conventions, the monstrous architecture, the victim count, the tabloid narrative, that true crime still uses today.
What happened to the Murder Castle building?
The building at 63rd and Wallace in Chicago burned down in 1895, approximately a year after Holmes's arrest, under circumstances that were never explained. A United States Post Office was eventually built on the site and remains there today.
