Horror Has Always Been Queer. The Genre Knew It Before Anyone Else Did.
Quick Answer
Has horror always been queer? Horror has had a documented queer presence since at least 1872, when Irish writer Sheridan Le Fanu published Carmilla, a novella about a female vampire seducing a young woman, 26 years before Dracula. The director of the 1931 Frankenstein, James Whale, was openly gay during Hollywood's studio era. Anne Rice's Interview with the Vampire (1976) centers a homoerotic relationship its author confirmed was always intentional. Horror provided a space for queer stories because it was already in the business of depicting what polite society refused to name.
Queer horror didn't begin with critics naming it. It was there in the vampire novella Bram Stoker read before writing Dracula, in the director who gave us Frankenstein and then watched the industry forget him, in the novelist who published a vampire love story in 1976 and confirmed years later that yes, that's what it was. The genre had been sheltering this content for over a century before anyone outside it said so out loud.
Carmilla came before Dracula
In 1872, Irish writer Sheridan Le Fanu published Carmilla. It is a novella about a female vampire named Carmilla who seduces a young woman named Laura. The attraction is physical. The horror and the desire are the same thing. The word "lesbian" does not appear because in 1872 it couldn't, but the relationship is not ambiguous. Laura is drawn to Carmilla in ways she cannot name and does not fully resist, and the danger and the longing are inseparable from each other the entire way through.
Carmilla predates Dracula by 26 years. Stoker had read Le Fanu. He borrowed the template: the victim drawn to the predator, the seduction that reads as illness, the blood that passes between bodies. He set it between a man and a woman, which the Victorian market required. But the mechanics were already built into the structure he inherited.
Two years before Dracula was published, Stoker's friend Oscar Wilde was convicted of gross indecency and sentenced to two years of hard labor. Stoker attended the trials. Whether Stoker was gay or bisexual himself is debated among scholars. That he was writing in full knowledge of what happened to men who loved men is not a question.
Frankenstein and the house it came from
Mary Shelley wrote Frankenstein at 18. She wrote it in 1816 in Switzerland, in a house that included Lord Byron, bisexual and already run out of England partly for it, and John Polidori, who would publish "The Vampyre" three years later and establish the aristocratic predatory vampire as a literary figure. Shelley had run away from England at 16 with Percy Shelley, who was married to someone else at the time. Her mother was Mary Wollstonecraft, who wrote A Vindication of the Rights of Woman in 1792. The entire circle organized its life around not doing what it was told.
The creature in Frankenstein is stitched together from pieces of other bodies, brought to life, and immediately rejected by his creator for being wrong. He wanders a world that has no category for what he is. Shelley was 18, living outside every sanctioned structure, and the book she wrote is about a being that exists outside every sanctioned structure. The people who have spent two centuries making authoritative claims about what is natural have always had trouble explaining Frankenstein.
James Whale gave us the monster
James Whale directed Frankenstein in 1931 and Bride of Frankenstein in 1935. He was openly gay in Hollywood during the studio era, which was unusual and, in the long run, career-ending. He also made The Old Dark House (1932) and The Invisible Man (1933). For a few years in the early 1930s he was one of the most distinctive directors working in the genre.
By the 1940s the studios had moved on. By 1957 he was found dead in his swimming pool at his home in Los Angeles. The coroner initially ruled it accidental drowning. A note was found later. It described years of physical decline and isolation. It read as an accounting of what the industry had taken from him.
The 1998 film Gods and Monsters depicts the last weeks of Whale's life, with Ian McKellen in the title role. McKellen had come out publicly in 1988, on a BBC radio program, in direct response to proposed legislation that would have criminalized the promotion of homosexuality to minors. The casting worked for the obvious reasons and also because it put two generations of the same history in the same frame.
Anne Rice made it explicit and Clive Barker kept it that way
Anne Rice published Interview with the Vampire in 1976. Lestat and Louis live together in a decaying New Orleans mansion and raise a child together. The relationship is, in every functional sense, a marriage without the word. Rice confirmed in later interviews that the homoerotic reading was always intentional. She grew up Catholic in New Orleans. The horror in the book is partly theological and partly about desire that the culture has no sanctioned outlet for, and what it costs to carry it anyway.
Clive Barker wrote The Hellbound Heart in 1986 and directed Hellraiser in 1987. He was openly gay. His horror is preoccupied with transgression, the body, and what desire demands from us when we pursue it past every warning. These themes carry a different weight when the person writing them grew up being told his body's desires were wrong. Horror can carry that weight. Most other genres are not built for it.
The Babadook and what the metaphor does on its own
In 2017, posts on Tumblr started treating the Babadook, the creature from Jennifer Kent's 2014 Australian horror film, as a gay icon. It started as a joke. It spread because the monster's defining characteristic mapped onto something real: a thing that lives in the house with you, that cannot be destroyed, only acknowledged and accepted. The film did not intend this reading. It didn't need to. Horror produces these readings because it is already organized around the creature that does not fit, and the audience that does not fit finds it first.
The genre didn't become queer when critics started writing about it that way. It was queer from Carmilla, from the director who made the monster and watched the industry move on without him, from the novelist who confirmed years later that the love story was always there. The rest of the culture is still catching up, which is fine. The genre was never waiting on it.
The Coming Out of the Grave T-shirt is for everyone who finds the overlap between horror and queerness less surprising than the people who just noticed it. The Skella Gay T-shirt is for the rest of you. The full Pride collection is for people who celebrate and protest in equal measure and see no contradiction between those two things. For the actual folklore behind vampires before Stoker arrived, Vampires Before Dracula covers where the myth came from, including the Le Fanu connection.
Murder Apparel is an independent, husband-and-wife brand making spooky, political gear for people who give a damn. We donate to fight injustice and support communities in need. 500,000+ weirdos on Instagram. Come find your people.
Frequently Asked Questions
Has horror always been queer?
Horror has had a documented queer presence since at least 1872, when Sheridan Le Fanu published Carmilla, a novella about a female vampire seducing a young woman, 26 years before Dracula. The director of the 1931 Frankenstein, James Whale, was openly gay during the Hollywood studio era. Anne Rice's Interview with the Vampire centers a homoerotic relationship its author later confirmed was intentional. Clive Barker, who created Hellraiser, was openly gay. The genre sheltered queer stories and creators for well over a century before mainstream culture developed a vocabulary for it.
What is Carmilla and why does it matter?
Carmilla is an 1872 vampire novella by Irish writer Sheridan Le Fanu about a female vampire, Carmilla, who preys on a young woman named Laura. The relationship is explicitly erotic by the standards available to a Victorian writer, and the horror of the story is inseparable from the transgressive desire at its center. Carmilla predates Dracula by 26 years, and Bram Stoker read it. The structural template of Carmilla, the victim drawn to the predator, the seduction that masquerades as illness, the intimacy of the feeding, runs directly through Dracula. It is where the modern vampire story actually begins.
Is Dracula queer?
Dracula has been analyzed for queer subtext by literary scholars since at least the 1980s. The novel features a count who pursues men and women with equal appetite, a male protagonist rendered passive and penetrated, and erotic tension the surface narrative cannot fully contain. Bram Stoker was personally close to Oscar Wilde, who was convicted of gross indecency in 1895, two years before Dracula was published. Stoker attended the Wilde trials. Whether Stoker himself was gay or bisexual is debated among biographers. That the book has substantial queer content is not.
Who was James Whale?
James Whale was a British film director who made Frankenstein (1931), Bride of Frankenstein (1935), The Old Dark House (1932), and The Invisible Man (1933). He was openly gay during Hollywood's studio era, which was unusual and ultimately career-ending. His career peaked in the early 1930s and had largely faded by the 1940s. He was found dead in his swimming pool in Los Angeles in 1957. A note discovered later described years of physical decline and isolation. His life was depicted in the 1998 film Gods and Monsters, with Ian McKellen playing Whale.
Why has horror been a refuge for queer storytelling?
Horror is organized around the thing that does not belong: the creature outside the natural order, the desire with no acceptable outlet, the person whose nature is treated as a threat to the community. These are also the terms in which queer people have historically been described, persecuted, and depicted. The genre had the vocabulary before it had the explicit subject. Queer writers found a form that could hold what other forms rejected. Queer audiences found stories that described their experience in a genre the culture would actually distribute. The fit was structural, not coincidental.
How did the Babadook become a queer icon?
In 2017, posts on Tumblr began treating the Babadook, the creature from Jennifer Kent's 2014 Australian horror film, as a gay icon. The posts were partly ironic. They spread because the creature's defining characteristic, it cannot be destroyed, only acknowledged and accepted into the household, worked as an accurate description of a specific kind of lived experience. The film did not intend this reading. Horror frequently produces readings the filmmakers did not plan, because the genre is built around the thing that does not fit and the people who do not fit find it.
