The History of Halloween: It's Darker Than You Think
Quick Answer
What is the history of Halloween? Halloween originated with the ancient Celtic festival of Samhain, observed on October 31 for at least 2,000 years as a night when the boundary between the living and the dead dissolved. The Roman Catholic Church gradually absorbed it into the Christian calendar as All Hallows Eve, the night before All Saints Day. Irish and Scottish immigrants brought Halloween traditions to America in the 19th century. Trick-or-treating as we know it did not become widespread until the 1930s and 1950s. Halloween is now a $12 billion industry in the United States, making it the second-largest commercial holiday after Christmas.
Halloween is 2,000 years old, has been declared dead by the Church at least twice, survived Puritans, crossed an ocean in the luggage of people fleeing famine, got sanitized into a neighborhood candy distribution event, and somehow came out the other side as the holiday most likely to be celebrated by people with skull tattoos and people with small children dressed as dinosaurs simultaneously. The history of Halloween is, in other words, extremely weird and worth knowing.
Samhain: Where It Actually Started
The Celtic festival of Samhain (pronounced "SAH-win") was observed by the ancient Celts of Ireland, Scotland, and northern France on October 31, marking the end of the harvest season and the beginning of winter. In the Celtic calendar, this was the new year. The transition between years was understood as a liminal time, a crack in the ordinary boundary between worlds, when the dead could walk among the living and spirits could cross over. This was not purely a terrifying prospect. The Celts also believed that the presence of the dead made it easier for priests, called Druids, to make prophecies about the coming year.
The Samhain celebrations involved large communal bonfires on hilltops, lit to guide benevolent spirits and repel harmful ones. People wore costumes, typically made from animal heads and skins, partly to disguise themselves from unfriendly spirits and partly as ritual connection to the animal world entering winter. They left food offerings outside their homes. The bonfire coals were used to relight home hearths that had been extinguished for the new year, a ritual of communal continuity. None of this involved candy corn.
Rome Tries to Help
When the Roman Empire conquered Celtic territory, it merged Samhain with two Roman festivals observed at roughly the same time of year. Feralia, held in late October, was a Roman day of honoring the dead. Pomona was a festival honoring the Roman goddess of fruit and trees, whose symbol was the apple. The incorporation of Pomona into the Samhain tradition is the most widely cited explanation for apple bobbing, which is now primarily experienced as a way to get your face wet at a party and has lost most of its religious significance.
The Church Takes a Run at It
The Roman Catholic Church made two major attempts to Christianize Samhain. In the 8th century, Pope Gregory III moved the feast of All Saints, a day honoring Christian martyrs and saints, from May to November 1. The night before became All Hallows Eve, which contracted over time into Halloween. A century later, the Church added All Souls Day on November 2, a day to pray for souls in purgatory. The intent was to replace the pagan festival of the dead with a Christian one and redirect the spiritual energy of the season toward Church-approved observance.
It mostly did not work. The old traditions persisted underneath the Christian calendar overlay. In medieval England and Ireland, practices like "souling" emerged: poor people would go door to door on All Souls Day offering to pray for the souls of the dead in exchange for food, particularly small spiced cakes called soul cakes. This is a recognizable ancestor of trick-or-treating. "Guising," the practice of young people dressing in costume and performing songs or tricks in exchange for food or money, was common in Scotland and Ireland centuries before the holiday reached America.
The Church's relationship with Halloween has never been fully resolved. Certain Christian traditions still actively discourage Halloween observance as incompatible with Christian faith, an objection that has been raised and mostly ignored for about twelve centuries.
Halloween Crosses the Atlantic
Halloween was not a significant holiday in early America. The Protestant communities that dominated colonial New England had little use for it. Samhain-derived celebrations were more common in the Southern colonies, where a more diverse European population mixed Halloween with Native American harvest festivals and created an early American version of the holiday focused on ghost stories, fortune telling, and communal gatherings.
The transformation came with immigration. The Irish Potato Famine of the 1840s drove roughly a million Irish immigrants to the United States in a very short period. They brought Halloween traditions with them in full: costumes, jack-o-lanterns (originally carved from turnips in Ireland, switched to the more available American pumpkin), and the cultural understanding of October 31 as a genuinely significant night. Scottish immigrants brought guising. By the late 19th century, Halloween was becoming a nationwide American holiday.
The late 19th and early 20th centuries saw a conscious effort to make Halloween more community-focused and less frightening. Women's magazines and community groups promoted Halloween parties with games like apple bobbing and fortune telling, deliberately steering the holiday toward neighborly fun and away from its associations with vandalism, which was a genuine problem: Halloween pranks had become increasingly destructive, and in some cities October 31 looked more like a riot than a celebration.
Trick-or-Treating Is Newer Than You Think
Structured trick-or-treating as Americans currently practice it, children in costume going door to door collecting candy from neighbors, did not become the standard Halloween activity until the 1930s and did not reach its current form until after World War II. Before the 1930s, Halloween was primarily an adult and community affair. The shift toward a children's candy-focused holiday was partly a deliberate strategy by community organizations to give children a structured, supervised alternative to the vandalism that had plagued the holiday for decades.
World War II interrupted the tradition almost immediately after it had taken hold. Sugar rationing made candy distribution difficult from 1942 to 1945. Trick-or-treating largely paused. After the war ended and rationing lifted, the suburban expansion of the late 1940s and 1950s created the ideal conditions for the door-to-door candy tradition: densely populated residential neighborhoods with young families, plenty of disposable income, and children who could walk safely between houses. The baby boom generation grew up trick-or-treating, and by the time they had children of their own it was an American institution.
The Always Check Your Candy Hoodie nods at one of the great Halloween moral panics, which brings us to the next section.
The Razor Blade Panic and the Myth of Stranger Danger
Beginning in the 1970s, stories circulated about strangers hiding razor blades, needles, and poison in Halloween candy given to children. The panic spread rapidly through the media and profoundly changed how Americans approached trick-or-treating: parents began inspecting and X-raying candy, hospitals offered free screening, and homemade treats from neighbors were treated as suspect.
Sociologist Joel Best spent years systematically researching alleged Halloween candy tampering cases. His findings, published in peer-reviewed research, were unambiguous: he could not find a single confirmed case of a stranger killing or seriously injuring a child by tampering with Halloween candy. The cases that did involve poisoned Halloween candy, a small number, involved family members targeting specific children for insurance or other reasons, not random strangers attacking neighborhood kids. The razor blade panic was, in Best's assessment, a moral panic driven by media coverage rather than a documented threat.
This did not stop the panic from becoming a permanent feature of American Halloween culture. The Man I Love Fall T-shirt exists for everyone who loves this season with full knowledge of all the above.
Halloween Now
Americans spend approximately $12 billion on Halloween annually, making it the second-largest commercial holiday in the country after Christmas. Adults now spend more on Halloween than children do. The holiday has expanded well beyond October 31: "spooky season" in popular culture begins in September, sometimes earlier. Spirit Halloween, a seasonal pop-up retailer, occupies abandoned big-box stores across the country for roughly three months a year and generates over $1 billion in annual revenue.
Underneath the commercial machinery, the original character of the holiday persists in the communities that kept it alive when it was unfashionable: goths, horror enthusiasts, pagans, and everyone who has always understood that one night a year when the rules about what is normal briefly relax is genuinely valuable. The 2,000-year-old instinct that the boundary between worlds thins in late October, that the dead deserve acknowledgment, and that dressing as something frightening is a reasonable response to a frightening world did not go anywhere. It just learned to coexist with fun-size Snickers.
Browse the full Halloween collection if you're the kind of person who treats October 31 as a religious observance, which, historically speaking, is exactly what it was.
And if you want to understand how the Church's attempt to suppress pagan practices played out in its most violent American chapter, the Salem Witch Trials post covers the same underlying story: The Salem Witch Trials: Nobody Who Was Executed Was a Witch.
Murder Apparel is an independent, husband-and-wife brand making spooky, political gear for people who give a damn. We donate to fight injustice and support communities in need. 500,000+ weirdos on Instagram. Come find your people.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where did Halloween originate?
Halloween originated with the ancient Celtic festival of Samhain, observed on October 31 for at least 2,000 years across Ireland, Scotland, and northern France. Samhain marked the end of the harvest season and the Celtic new year, and was understood as a night when the boundary between the living and the dead dissolved. The Roman Catholic Church gradually absorbed the festival into the Christian calendar as All Hallows Eve, the night before All Saints Day, though the underlying pagan traditions persisted for centuries.
What does Samhain mean?
Samhain is an ancient Celtic word meaning roughly "summer's end." It is pronounced "SAH-win" in Irish Gaelic. The festival marked the transition from the light half of the year to the dark half, the end of harvest and the beginning of winter. In the Celtic worldview, this threshold time was understood as a period when the boundary between the world of the living and the world of the dead became permeable, allowing spirits to cross between realms. Modern Wiccans and pagans continue to observe Samhain as a religious holiday.
When did trick-or-treating start?
Trick-or-treating in its modern form, children in costume going door to door for candy, became widespread in the United States in the 1930s and reached its current form after World War II in the late 1940s and 1950s. Earlier versions existed in medieval Europe as "souling" and "guising," practices where people went door to door offering prayers or performances in exchange for food. The American version was partly a deliberate community strategy to channel Halloween energy away from vandalism and into supervised children's activities.
Is the Halloween candy tampering threat real?
Research by sociologist Joel Best found no confirmed cases of a stranger killing or seriously injuring a child by tampering with Halloween candy. The small number of actual poisoning cases involving Halloween candy involved family members targeting specific children, not random strangers. The widespread panic about razor blades and poison in candy, which began circulating in the 1970s, was a moral panic driven by media coverage rather than documented incidents. Most hospitals and community organizations that promoted candy inspection did so in response to fears that were not supported by verified cases.
Why do we carve pumpkins for Halloween?
Jack-o-lanterns derive from an Irish tradition of carving faces into turnips or potatoes and placing lit candles inside them, originally to ward off spirits on Samhain. Irish immigrants who came to America in the 19th century found pumpkins, which are native to North America, much easier to carve than turnips. The American pumpkin replaced the Irish turnip, and the tradition became one of the most recognizable symbols of Halloween. The name "jack-o-lantern" comes from the Irish legend of Stingy Jack, a man who tricked the devil and was condemned to wander the earth with only a carved coal inside a turnip to light his way.
Why does the Church oppose Halloween?
Some Christian traditions oppose Halloween because of its origins in Samhain, a pre-Christian Celtic festival, and because of its association with death, spirits, and occult imagery. The objection is not universal across Christianity: many Christians celebrate Halloween without concern. The Roman Catholic Church effectively created the Christian version of the holiday when it placed All Saints Day on November 1 and All Souls Day on November 2, deliberately overlapping with Samhain. The tension between Halloween's pagan roots and its Christian overlay has never been fully resolved, and certain Protestant and evangelical communities continue to discourage or prohibit observance.
