The History of the Jack-o'-Lantern: From Turnips to Pumpkins
Quick Answer
Where does the jack-o'-lantern come from? The jack-o'-lantern originates in Irish and British folk tradition, specifically the legend of Stingy Jack, a trickster figure who twice tricked the devil and was consequently barred from both heaven and hell after his death. Condemned to wander the earth in darkness, Jack was given a single burning coal to light his way, which he carried in a carved-out turnip. Irish and Scottish immigrants carved faces into turnips, beets, and potatoes during Samhain to represent or ward off wandering spirits. When these communities arrived in America in large numbers following the Great Famine of the 1840s, they found the pumpkin, native to North America, far easier to carve than any European root vegetable. The pumpkin substitution happened in America. The tradition's origin is Irish. The name "jack-o'-lantern" predates Halloween carvings entirely: it was an older English term for the will-o'-the-wisp, the strange lights seen over bogs and marshes at night.
The jack-o'-lantern was a turnip before it was a pumpkin, and it was a ghost light before it was either. The carved, illuminated faces on front porches every October are the end product of a folk tradition that moved across the Atlantic in the luggage of famine refugees and got a vegetable upgrade on arrival. Stingy Jack wandered the earth with his coal in a turnip. Irish immigrants carved their turnips in the new world and discovered pumpkins. The rest is the decoration aisle at every American grocery store from September onward. Here is how it actually happened.
Stingy Jack: The Legend
The Stingy Jack legend, documented in Irish folklore, concerns a man variously described as a blacksmith, a drunkard, or simply a trickster of exceptional cunning and moral vacancy. Jack encountered the devil and, through two separate tricks, managed to trap him, extracting promises that the devil would not claim Jack's soul when he died. The versions of the trick vary: in one, Jack convinces the devil to climb a tree and then carves a cross in the bark, trapping him; in another, he traps the devil in a coin or a snuffbox. The consistent element is that Jack, through cleverness, secured his afterlife exemption through contract rather than virtue.
When Jack eventually died, he was refused entry to heaven on straightforward grounds of character. He went to the devil to claim his contractual exemption from hell, and the devil, honoring the terms, turned him away. Condemned to walk the dark between worlds indefinitely, Jack asked for at least something to light his way. The devil gave him a burning coal from the fires of hell. Jack, who had picked up an apple on his way through, or in some versions carried a carved-out turnip, placed the coal inside and used it as his lantern. He has been walking ever since, the original will-o'-the-wisp, carrying his little light through the dark.
Samhain and the Carved Vegetables
In Ireland and Scotland, the period of Samhain (roughly October 31 to November 1) was the liminal time of year when the boundary between the living and the dead was considered permeable. Spirits of the dead could cross into the living world, and other, more ambiguous entities moved freely during these days. The practice of carving frightening faces into turnips, beets, and potatoes and placing candles or coals inside them served multiple purposes in this context: they represented the spirits themselves, giving them a visible form; they were placed in windows or at doors to warn spirits that the household was already spiritually occupied; or they were carried by people moving at night to frighten off malevolent spirits.
The carved turnip lanterns of Ireland and Scotland were not decorative in the modern sense. They were functional objects within a belief system that took seriously the idea of wandering dead during Samhain. The faces were meant to be frightening because frightening faces keep frightening things away. The turnip, a hardy, dense root vegetable, was difficult to carve and produced a rough, jagged result that was probably more genuinely unsettling than a smoothly carved pumpkin face in any case. If you have ever tried to carve a raw turnip, you understand why the Irish were immediately interested when they encountered pumpkins.
The Name "Jack-o'-Lantern" Before Halloween
The term "jack-o'-lantern" is recorded in English before it was associated with carved vegetables at all. Its earliest documented uses refer to the will-o'-the-wisp, the strange lights sometimes seen hovering over marshes, bogs, and swamps at night, produced by the combustion of gases from decomposing organic matter in waterlogged ground. These lights, which flickered and moved and led travelers off the path, were explained in folk belief as the lanterns of wandering spirits, and the spirit most commonly associated with them was some version of the Stingy Jack figure: a man condemned to wander between worlds, carrying his light. "Jack" was a generic name for a mischievous male spirit in English folk tradition, the same way "Jack" names Jack Frost, Flapjack, and various other folk figures.
When the Irish carving tradition arrived in America, the carved vegetable lanterns were recognized as the same kind of object the older English term had described: a light carried by a wandering spirit, or made to represent one. The name transferred. The carved turnip lantern became the jack-o'-lantern in the American context, linking the vegetable carving tradition to the older atmospheric light phenomenon and the wandering spirit folk figure in a single terminological move.
The Great Famine and the Pumpkin Substitution
The Irish were already emigrating to North America before the Great Famine of 1845 to 1852, but the Famine produced emigration at a scale that permanently changed both Ireland and the United States. Approximately one million people died and another million emigrated during the Famine years alone, with emigration continuing at high rates for decades afterward. The Irish communities that established themselves in American cities, primarily Boston, New York, and Philadelphia, brought their Halloween traditions with them, including the carved lantern practice.
North American pumpkins, native to the continent and cultivated by Indigenous peoples for thousands of years, were already a common agricultural product in the northeastern United States by the time Irish immigrants arrived in large numbers. The pumpkin is larger than a turnip, hollow rather than solid, thin-walled, and easy to carve with a knife. The substitution required no philosophical commitment: the pumpkin simply worked better for the purpose. The first recorded American reference to a pumpkin jack-o'-lantern dates to approximately 1866, in a Canadian newspaper's description of Halloween celebrations.
How Pumpkin Carving Became an American Institution
The transition from immigrant folk tradition to mainstream American Halloween practice happened gradually through the late 19th century and accelerated in the early 20th. Halloween itself was not a major commercial or community holiday in the United States until the early 20th century, when community organizations began promoting it as a neighborhood celebration for children. The pumpkin jack-o'-lantern, as a visual centerpiece of the holiday that was non-threatening, festive, and suitable for families, was a natural fit for this sanitized version of the holiday and became its primary visual symbol.
The commercial pumpkin carving market, including the pre-carved jack-o'-lantern stencil, the electric light substitute, and eventually the synthetic foam pumpkin, all developed from the basic practice that Irish immigrants brought to America from a tradition that itself derived from a folk legend about a man who was too clever and not good enough to get into either heaven or hell. Stingy Jack would probably appreciate the irony of his coal-in-a-turnip becoming a billion-dollar seasonal industry.
Jack-o'-Lanterns as Art and Statement
Contemporary jack-o'-lantern carving has developed well beyond the simple triangle-eye, gap-tooth grin face of the mid-20th century. Competitive and artistic pumpkin carving is a recognized practice with its own community, tools, and techniques. The carved pumpkin has become a medium for portraits, landscapes, political statements, and pop culture references, which is a long journey from a frightened Irish farmer's turnip in a window during Samhain but is consistent with how folk traditions evolve: the form persists, the content updates, and the original meaning becomes archaeology for people willing to look it up.
The Pumpkin Queen T-Shirt is for everyone who has read the full origin story of why we carve pumpkins in October and arrived at the correct conclusion that it is both extremely weird and extremely good. The full Halloween collection is for everyone who takes the season seriously, which is the only way to take it. For the complete history of how Halloween traditions developed and the folk practices that preceded them, the history of trick-or-treating covers the tradition that grew up alongside jack-o'-lanterns from the same Irish and Celtic roots.
Murder Apparel is an independent, husband-and-wife brand making spooky, political gear for people who give a damn. We donate to fight injustice and support communities in need. 500,000+ weirdos on Instagram. Come find your people.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the origin of the jack-o'-lantern?
The jack-o'-lantern originates in Irish and British folk tradition, specifically the Stingy Jack legend, in which a trickster who tricked the devil is condemned to wander the earth carrying a burning coal in a carved turnip. Irish and Scottish communities carved frightening faces into turnips, beets, and potatoes during Samhain to represent wandering spirits or ward them off. When Irish immigrants arrived in America in large numbers after the Great Famine of the 1840s, they substituted pumpkins, which were native to North America and far easier to carve. The first recorded American pumpkin jack-o'-lantern dates to approximately 1866.
Who is Stingy Jack?
Stingy Jack is a figure from Irish folklore, a clever and morally deficient trickster who twice tricked the devil and secured a promise that his soul would not be taken at death. When Jack died, he was refused entry to heaven on grounds of character and turned away from hell by the devil honoring his bargain. Condemned to wander the earth between worlds, Jack was given a burning coal by the devil for light. He placed it in a carved-out turnip to carry it. The wandering Jack with his turnip lantern is the folk figure behind both the carved Halloween pumpkin and the older English use of "jack-o'-lantern" to describe will-o'-the-wisp lights over bogs and marshes.
Why were original jack-o'-lanterns carved from turnips?
Turnips were the available large root vegetable in Ireland and Scotland, where the carving tradition originated. They were carved during Samhain, the autumn festival marking the boundary between the living and the dead, and used to represent wandering spirits or frighten malevolent ones away. The practice predates the use of pumpkins, which are native to North America and were unknown in Ireland before contact with the Americas. When Irish immigrants arrived in America, they found pumpkins significantly easier to carve than turnips, which are dense, solid, and difficult to hollow out. The vegetable substitution was practical, not symbolic.
What does "jack-o'-lantern" mean and where does the name come from?
The term "jack-o'-lantern" predates Halloween carving and was originally an English name for the will-o'-the-wisp, the strange lights seen hovering over marshes and bogs at night, produced by gases from decomposing organic matter. These lights were explained in folk belief as the lanterns of wandering spirits. "Jack" was a generic English folk name for a mischievous male spirit. When Irish immigrants brought their carved vegetable lantern tradition to America, the name transferred to the carved pumpkins, linking them to the older atmospheric lights and the wandering spirit folk figure they had in common.
When did pumpkin carving become a Halloween tradition in America?
The transition happened in the second half of the 19th century and became mainstream in the early 20th. Irish immigrants brought the carved lantern tradition to America in large numbers following the Great Famine of the 1840s-1850s, and pumpkins quickly replaced turnips as the carving medium. The first recorded American reference to a pumpkin jack-o'-lantern is approximately 1866. Halloween itself was not a major commercial holiday in the United States until the early 20th century, when community organizations began promoting it as a neighborhood celebration. The pumpkin jack-o'-lantern became the holiday's primary visual symbol through this period.
What is the connection between jack-o'-lanterns and Samhain?
Samhain was the Celtic and Irish festival marking approximately October 31 to November 1, the end of the harvest and the beginning of the dark half of the year. In Irish folk belief, Samhain was the time when the boundary between the living and the dead was permeable, allowing spirits to cross into the living world. Carved vegetable lanterns were made during this period specifically in connection with these beliefs, representing wandering spirits or serving as protective talismans to ward off malevolent ones. The Samhain traditions, including the carved lanterns, were carried into the American Halloween by Irish immigrants and became the foundation of the secular holiday that developed through the 19th and 20th centuries.
