Why Frogs Are Witchy: The Real History of Frogs, Toads, and Magic
Quick Answer
Why are frogs associated with witchcraft? Frogs and toads have been linked to magic and witchcraft for thousands of years across multiple cultures, for reasons that make complete sense once you understand the logic. They are liminal creatures, living between water and land, between worlds, which in nearly every magical tradition makes them symbols of threshold and transformation. Toad skin contains psychoactive compounds documented in medieval "flying ointment" recipes. Toads were the most commonly reported witch familiar in English witch trial records, including at Salem. The frog-headed goddess Heket was one of ancient Egypt's most important deities. Shakespeare put a toad at the top of the Macbeth cauldron ingredient list. The connection between frogs and witchcraft is not aesthetic coincidence. It is a very long documented history.
Frogs are witchy. Not because someone in 2015 decided the cottage core aesthetic needed a mascot, though that happened too. Because frogs have been associated with magic, witchcraft, transformation, and the liminal spaces between worlds for literally thousands of years, across cultures that never talked to each other. Ancient Egypt. Greece and Rome. Medieval England. Colonial Massachusetts. The Macbeth cauldron. If that many independent traditions arrived at the same conclusion about an animal, the animal is doing something to earn it.
The Liminal Creature
The core reason frogs keep ending up in magical traditions is simple: they live in two worlds. A frog is born in water, breathes through its skin, transforms from a water-breathing tadpole into an air-breathing land animal, and then spends the rest of its life moving between both. It belongs to neither element fully. It exists at the threshold.
Threshold is where magic happens, in virtually every tradition that has ever thought about it. The crossroads (between paths). Midnight (between days). The new moon (between visible and invisible). The shore (between water and land). Magic is by definition liminal, operating in the space where one category ends and another hasn't started yet. An animal that literally lives in that space, that physiologically embodies the in-between, was always going to end up associated with magic. The frog didn't choose this reputation. The frog earned it by being what it is.
Ancient Egypt: The Frog Goddess
Heket was an ancient Egyptian goddess depicted with the head of a frog, and she was not a minor deity. Heket was the goddess of fertility, birth, and the final stages of labor. Midwives in ancient Egypt were known as "servants of Heket." Her frog amulets have been found in tombs and homes dating back to the Old Kingdom, roughly 2700 BCE. For ancient Egyptians, frogs were a symbol of new life and transformation specifically because the annual Nile flooding produced enormous numbers of frogs appearing from the mud, which was understood as frogs spontaneously generating from the earth itself. Life appearing from nothing. Transformation from the inert to the living. If you are building a pantheon of deities, and you want a goddess of birth and new life, a frog-headed goddess is not a weird choice. It is a very logical one.
The Ten Plagues of Egypt in the Book of Exodus include frogs as the second plague, which, read in context, is a direct challenge to Heket: the god of Moses can produce frogs in overwhelming, nightmarish quantities, overwhelming the goddess of frogs. That reading is contested among biblical scholars, but it illustrates how deeply the frog-as-sacred symbol was embedded in Egyptian culture that a competing religious tradition would use frogs as a weapon against it.
Toad Familiars and the Witch Trials
In English witchcraft mythology and trial records, the witch's familiar was an animal spirit that served the witch, fed from her blood via a "witch's mark" (a mole, skin tag, or other blemish on the body), and carried out her magical work. Cats were the most famous familiars, but toads were close behind. The Matthew Hopkins witch trials of 1645-1647 in East Anglia, which produced more executions than any other witch hunt in English history, featured multiple accused witches with toad familiars. One accused woman described a toad familiar named Vinegar Tom. Trial records repeatedly documented suspected witches feeding toads from their bodies, keeping them in special pots, and sending them to harm neighbors.
At Salem in 1692, familiar spirits appeared in testimony repeatedly. The specific creatures described varied, but toads and frog-like creatures appear in the witness accounts. The logic of the familiar system made toads perfect candidates: they appeared in dark and damp places, they were associated in folk belief with poison (toad skin secretions are toxic to many predators), and they had the right quality of wrongness, the not-quite-right texture and appearance of something that might be more than it seemed. For the full history of what actually happened at Salem, the record is grim: nobody executed was a witch, and the toads were not guilty either.
Flying Ointments and What Toad Skin Actually Does
Here is where the frog and witchcraft connection gets pharmacologically interesting. Medieval and early modern accounts of witchcraft frequently describe witches applying an ointment to their skin, often described as being made from the fat of unbaptized children combined with various herbs and other ingredients, that allowed them to fly to the Sabbath. Historians of pharmacology who have analyzed the ingredient lists in surviving "flying ointment" recipes have found them to be full of genuinely psychoactive substances: belladonna, henbane, mandrake, wolfsbane. Applied to the skin through mucous membranes, these plants can produce powerful hallucinogenic experiences, including sensations of flying.
Some of those same recipes include toad skin or toad secretions. Toad skin, specifically the skin of Bufo toad species, contains bufadienolides and bufotenine, compounds with documented psychoactive properties. Bufotenine is a psychedelic alkaloid. Toads weren't just symbolically associated with witchcraft. They may have been pharmacologically associated with it, as actual ingredients in preparations that produced altered states of consciousness. The witch's familiar toad was not just a pet. In at least some documented folk magic traditions, it was also medicine.
Shakespeare Put a Toad First
When the three witches in Macbeth gather around their cauldron in Act IV, the first ingredient they throw in is a toad: "Toad, that under cold stone / Days and nights has thirty-one / Swelter'd venom sleeping got / Boil thou first i' the charmed pot." Shakespeare was writing for an audience that understood the reference immediately. By 1606, when Macbeth was first performed, the toad as a witch's ingredient, a witch's familiar, and a creature of poison and dark magic was so thoroughly established in English popular culture that Shakespeare could open his most famous witch scene with a toad and expect every person in the Globe to get it. The toad was the establishing shot. It told the audience what kind of scene they were watching before the witches had said another word.
The Cottage Witch and the Modern Frog Revival
The contemporary "cottage witch" aesthetic that has dominated witchcraft TikTok, Pinterest, and the broader modern witchcraft revival for the past decade is essentially a reclamation of the historical frog-witch connection, whether its practitioners know that history or not. Mushrooms, herbs, forests, cauldrons, and frogs sitting on mossy logs in the rain: this visual language draws on the same symbolic system that put toads in the Macbeth cauldron. The frog as a symbol of the in-between, of nature magic, of transformation, of the quiet power of things that live at thresholds and get overlooked by everyone who is only looking at the spectacular. The Cottage Frog Forest T-shirt is for the people who looked at the entire canon of Western magical symbolism and correctly identified the frog as the protagonist the whole time.
The internet's "frog girl" phenomenon, the deep and enthusiastic subset of people who specifically and intensely love frogs as an identity, has significant demographic overlap with the modern witchcraft revival. This is not coincidental. Both communities are drawn to liminality, to things that don't quite fit, to the wet and the dark and the transformative, to creatures and practices that mainstream culture finds slightly wrong in a way that feels exactly right to the right people. The frog has always been there at the edge of the firelight, doing its thing, waiting to be understood.
The Man I Love Frogs MILF T-shirt is for people who have done the reading, absorbed the history, and arrived at a fully considered position. The full Witchy Vibes collection is for everyone who finds the frog's résumé, Egyptian goddess servant, familiar spirit, cauldron ingredient, psychedelic toad, liminal being between worlds, more impressive than whatever anyone else is claiming on their behalf.
Murder Apparel is an independent, husband-and-wife brand making spooky, political gear for people who give a damn. We donate to fight injustice and support communities in need. 500,000+ weirdos on Instagram. Come find your people.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why are frogs and toads associated with witchcraft?
Frogs and toads have been linked to witchcraft and magic across multiple cultures for thousands of years, primarily because they are liminal creatures that live between two worlds, water and land, which in most magical traditions makes them symbols of threshold and transformation. In English witchcraft tradition, toads were the most common witch's familiar after cats. Toad skin contains psychoactive compounds (including bufotenine) that appear in historical recipes for "flying ointments." Ancient Egyptian religion featured a frog-headed goddess of birth and transformation. The connection is documented, independently arrived at, and not accidental.
What is a witch's familiar?
A witch's familiar was, in English witchcraft belief and legal tradition, an animal spirit that served a witch, carrying out magical work and receiving nourishment from the witch's blood through a "witch's mark" on her body. Familiars appeared extensively in English witch trial records from the 16th through 18th centuries. Cats were the most famous familiars, but toads appeared nearly as often. The Matthew Hopkins witch trials of 1645-1647 in East Anglia featured multiple accused witches described as keeping toad familiars and feeding them from their bodies. The familiar system explained why accused witches kept animals, the pets themselves became evidence of guilt.
Who was the Egyptian frog goddess?
Heket was an ancient Egyptian goddess depicted with a frog head, associated with fertility, birth, and the final stages of labor. She was a significant deity, not a minor one, midwives in ancient Egypt were known as "servants of Heket," and frog amulets connected to her have been found in Egyptian tombs and homes dating back to at least 2700 BCE. Frogs were associated with new life in ancient Egypt because the annual Nile flooding produced enormous numbers of frogs apparently generating from the mud, which was interpreted as spontaneous generation of life from the earth. A frog goddess of birth is, in this context, a logical choice.
What did toads have to do with flying ointments?
Medieval and early modern "flying ointment" recipes, which described preparations witches allegedly applied to their skin to fly to the Sabbath, frequently included psychoactive plants like belladonna, henbane, mandrake, and wolfsbane alongside toad skin or toad secretions. Toad skin, particularly from Bufo toad species, contains bufadienolides and bufotenine, a psychedelic alkaloid with documented hallucinogenic properties. Historians of pharmacology believe these ointments, applied to skin or mucous membranes, could produce genuine altered states including sensations of flying. The toad in these recipes was not purely symbolic. It was possibly pharmacologically functional.
Why did Shakespeare put a toad in the Macbeth cauldron?
When the witches in Macbeth open their cauldron scene (Act IV), the first ingredient is a "toad that under cold stone / days and nights has thirty-one / swelter'd venom sleeping got." Shakespeare was using cultural shorthand his audience already understood: by 1606, toads were so thoroughly established as a witch's animal, a familiar, an ingredient, a symbol of poison and dark magic, that opening a witch scene with a toad immediately signaled the nature of what was happening. The toad didn't need explanation. It was the establishing visual for the whole scene.
What is the cottage witch aesthetic and why does it involve frogs?
The cottage witch aesthetic is a contemporary witchcraft and folk-magic aesthetic centered on forests, herbs, mushrooms, natural magic, and a general relationship with the wet, dark, and liminal aspects of the natural world. Frogs appear prominently in this aesthetic because they fit its symbolic logic perfectly: they are creatures of the threshold between water and land, they are associated with transformation (their life cycle from egg to tadpole to frog), they appear in rain and at night, and they have been connected to nature magic and witchcraft in Western tradition for centuries. The cottage witch frog is not a random aesthetic choice. It draws, consciously or not, on a very long history.
