Why Goths Can't Be Racist
Quick Answer
Why can't goths be racist? Goth as a subculture is built on identifying with the outsider, the rejected, the monster that mainstream society refuses to accept. White supremacy is not the outsider. It is the mainstream power structure. The musical roots of goth trace directly to Black American artists. The literary tradition goth takes its name from is fundamentally about sympathizing with what the dominant culture fears and destroys. Racism is structurally incompatible with those foundations, which is why the goth community has historically and explicitly rejected white supremacist infiltration attempts.
Post-punk became goth. Post-punk came from punk. Punk came from rock and roll. Rock and roll came from Black Americans. At some point in that chain, a lot of goths forgot the most important part.
That forgetting has consequences. Here's the full history.
Where goth actually came from
The musical genealogy is not complicated. The blues developed in the American South in the late 19th century. From the blues came rhythm and blues. From R&B came rock and roll. The people who created that music: Robert Johnson, Howlin' Wolf, Chuck Berry, Little Richard, Muddy Waters. They were Black Americans. Elvis Presley sold millions of records covering material they originated. This dynamic is not unique to goth. It is the origin story of almost all popular music in the 20th century.
What is specific to goth is that it claims to be a subculture of outsiders, misfits, and the rejected. And then repeated the same pattern anyway.
Glam rock is the link between rock and roll and what became goth. David Bowie built his entire career on outsiderdom, gender nonconformity, and the persona of the alien who doesn't belong. He was also shaped by Little Richard, Jimi Hendrix, and the soul music he absorbed growing up in Brixton. When punk arrived, it explicitly borrowed from reggae and dub. The Clash released a reggae cover as one of their early singles. The dub aesthetic — heavy bass, reverb, space in the mix — ran directly into post-punk. We covered the full arc in the punk history post.
Bauhaus recorded "Bela Lugosi's Dead" in 1979. The song is often called the first goth record. It also sounds like dub. The bass line sits in the pocket the way Jamaican sound system music does. Peter Murphy and Daniel Ash were not hiding their influences. The Cure's Robert Smith has cited Jimi Hendrix. Siouxsie Sioux was shaped by Bowie, who was shaped by Black American artists. The DNA runs in one direction, and it is not the direction the mainstream image of goth suggests.
Gothic literature was always about the other
The literary tradition goth takes its name from has a consistent argument running through it. In Mary Shelley's Frankenstein, published in 1818, the monster is not the villain. The monster is the one society refuses to see as human. The creature is intelligent, articulate, capable of love, and driven to violence only after being rejected at every turn by people who judge him by his appearance. The horror is not the monster. The horror is everyone else.
In Bram Stoker's Dracula, published in 1897, the vampire is a foreign aristocrat from Eastern Europe who the English establishment fears will contaminate and corrupt them. Scholars have been reading Dracula as a text about racial anxiety since the 1970s. The fear of the foreign Other, the threat of mixing, the monster who comes from somewhere else. Stoker wrote Victorian England's racial panic into the story. The "monster" is what the dominant culture fears from outside its borders.
Gothic literature's entire project is to make you sympathize with what mainstream society fears and destroys. The monster, the witch, the vampire, the ghost: they are always the rejected, the misunderstood, the ones the respectable world wants to eliminate. If you use gothic aesthetics to enforce the hierarchy that creates the monster in the first place, you've missed what the books were doing. You are the village with the torches. You are the thing the genre is critiquing.
Black goth has always existed
The idea that goth is a white subculture was a media construction, not an accurate picture of who was actually in the clubs. Black goths were part of the scene from the beginning in the UK and the US. The mainstream press that covered goth in the 1980s had its own reasons to center white faces. The people actually there knew differently.
The documentary "Afropunk," released in 2003, made visible what had always been true: Black kids who were into punk, goth, and alternative music had been there the whole time. They were building their own spaces inside and alongside a scene that often erased them. The Afropunk Festival that grew from that documentary became one of the largest alternative music festivals in the world. It was not inventing something new. It was making something visible that had been obscured.
The Afrogoth movement, Black gothic social media communities, and generations of Black musicians working in the goth and darkwave space have all made the same point repeatedly: the monochrome version of goth history was always wrong. The subculture was never white. It was photographed and written about as though it were.
White supremacists tried. The scene rejected them.
In the 1980s and 1990s, neo-Nazi groups in Europe made deliberate efforts to recruit from goth and industrial music scenes. They were drawn to the death imagery, the black aesthetics, the Norse mythology some bands referenced. This was documented. It was not hypothetical. There were incidents at clubs. There were attempts at infiltration.
The goth community pushed back. Clubs banned Nazi imagery. Publications addressed it directly. Bands made their positions explicit. The rejection was coherent because it had to be: fascism demands conformity, racial purity, and identification with the dominant group. It demands you see yourself as part of the mainstream and destroy everything outside it. That is structurally opposite to what goth is. We covered what fascism actually is in the fascism post. The short version here is that fascism cannot coexist with a subculture built on celebrating the outsider, because fascism is the mainstream enforced at gunpoint.
The structural argument
This is the one that settles it. Goth as an identity is built on identifying with the rejected. The monster. The witch. The vampire. The misfit. The one who doesn't belong in the normal world and has stopped trying to.
White supremacy is not the monster. White supremacy is the village. It is the torch-carrying crowd. It is the dominant power structure that decides which bodies are acceptable and which are threats. It is the oldest and most persistent form of mainstream conformity in Western history.
You cannot claim to be on the side of the monster and also be the one who decides which people count as human. That is not a gray area. It is a direct contradiction of every value the subculture is built on.
The product description for this shirt says it plainly: being goth isn't about the clothes or the music. It's about rejecting prejudice, conformity, and systems that devalue people. Racism is a system that devalues people. If you're goth and you're racist, you have not found an edge case. You have simply contradicted yourself.
The music came from Black artists. The literature was about the monster society rejects. The subculture was built on celebrating what the mainstream fears. Bringing white supremacy into that is not a deviation from goth. It is goth's opposite.
The Goths Against Racism T-shirt is in the shop, along with the rest of the gothic collection.
Murder Apparel is an independent, husband-and-wife brand making spooky, political gear for people who give a damn. We donate to fight injustice and support communities in need. 500,000+ weirdos on Instagram. Come find your people.
Frequently asked questions
Why can't goths be racist?
Goth as a subculture is structurally built on identifying with the outsider, the rejected, the monster that mainstream society fears and destroys. White supremacy is not the outsider. It is the mainstream power structure, the dominant hierarchy that has shaped Western society for centuries. Claiming to identify with the rejected while enforcing racism is a direct contradiction: you are simultaneously claiming to be the monster and the village with the torches. Beyond the ideological argument, goth's musical roots trace directly to Black American artists, and its literary roots are in a tradition that consistently asks readers to sympathize with the creature the dominant culture cannot accept.
Where did goth music come from?
Goth emerged from post-punk in the late 1970s and early 1980s, with bands like Bauhaus, Siouxsie and the Banshees, The Cure, and Joy Division defining the sound. Post-punk came from punk, which borrowed heavily from Jamaican reggae and dub music. The dub aesthetic (heavy bass, reverb, atmospheric space) runs directly through the early goth sound. Punk came from rock and roll, which was created by Black American artists in the mid-20th century. The glam rock period that connected rock and roll to punk featured artists like David Bowie, whose career was shaped by Black American musicians including Little Richard and Jimi Hendrix. The Black musical influence on goth is not peripheral. It is the foundation.
What is Afropunk?
Afropunk began as a 2003 documentary by James Spooner about Black people in the punk scene who felt erased from mainstream representations of punk and alternative music. The film documented something that had always existed but was rarely acknowledged: Black kids building lives and identities inside a subculture that pretended they weren't there. The Afropunk Festival grew from that documentary and became one of the largest alternative music events in the world, eventually expanding internationally. The Afrogoth movement runs parallel, specifically addressing the presence and erasure of Black people in goth subculture. Both are naming something that was always true, not creating something new.
Did white supremacists try to infiltrate goth?
Yes. In the 1980s and 1990s, neo-Nazi groups in Europe, particularly in Germany, made documented attempts to recruit from goth and industrial music scenes, drawn to the death imagery and dark aesthetic. The goth community's response was largely explicit rejection. Clubs banned Nazi symbolism. Publications addressed the infiltration attempts directly. The rejection held because goth and fascism are structurally incompatible: fascism demands conformity, racial purity, and identification with the dominant group. Goth celebrates exactly what fascism destroys. They cannot coexist without one of them giving up what it is.
What does "gothic" mean in literature?
Gothic literature is a tradition that developed in the 18th century and centers on darkness, mystery, the supernatural, and the outsider. Key works include Horace Walpole's The Castle of Otranto (1764), Mary Shelley's Frankenstein (1818), and Bram Stoker's Dracula (1897). Scholars have long read gothic literature as a genre that gives voice to social anxieties about race, gender, class, and the fear of the Other, by placing those anxieties in the figure of the monster or the threat from outside. Crucially, the gothic tradition almost always asks readers to sympathize with the rejected creature rather than the respectable society that rejects it. The monster is not the villain. The village with the torches usually is.
Is goth a political subculture?
Goth did not begin as an explicitly political subculture in the way punk did. Punk had anti-establishment politics built into its public identity from the start. Goth focused more on aesthetics, darkness, and the interior emotional landscape. But because goth is built on identifying with what mainstream society rejects, it has always had an implicit political dimension. Any subculture that celebrates the outsider, the deviant, the misunderstood, and the non-conforming is making a statement about the society that created those categories. The explicit anti-racist politics visible in the Afropunk movement, the goth community's rejection of neo-Nazi infiltration, and shirts like Goths Against Racism are making that implicit dimension explicit.
