Jack-O'-Lanterns Were Never Pumpkins: The Real Origin Story
Quick Answer
Where did jack-o'-lanterns come from and why are they carved from pumpkins? The jack-o'-lantern originated in Irish folklore surrounding a figure called Stingy Jack, a trickster who twice outsmarted the Devil and was consequently barred from both heaven and hell after his death. Condemned to wander the dark with only a burning coal for light, he placed it in a carved turnip. The Irish carved their own turnip lanterns to ward off Jack and other wandering spirits during Samhain, the Celtic festival marking the boundary between the living and the dead. When Irish immigrants arrived in America during the mid-1800s, they found pumpkins were larger, easier to carve, and abundant. The pumpkin replaced the turnip. The tradition stayed. The original carved turnip jack-o'-lantern looked nothing like the grinning orange face you know today.
Stingy Jack tricked the Devil twice and got himself banned from both heaven and hell. He has been wandering in the dark ever since, with a burning coal in a carved turnip for a lamp. The Irish put that lamp in their windows every autumn to keep him away. Then they came to America and found pumpkins.
That is the actual origin story. The rest is immigration history and a bigger gourd.
The two tricks that started everything
The legend varies in its details depending on who is telling it, but the structure is consistent. Jack was an Irish blacksmith, or a farmer, or a drunk, depending on the version. Probably all three. He was known for being a miser and a manipulator and for being very good at talking his way out of things.
The first trick: Jack convinced the Devil to climb an apple tree to fetch him some fruit. While the Devil was up there, Jack carved crosses into the bark of the trunk. The Devil couldn't climb down past them. Jack made him promise never to claim his soul in exchange for removing the carvings. The Devil agreed. Jack removed the crosses.
The second trick: Jack persuaded the Devil to turn himself into a coin to pay for their drinks at a pub. Jack put the coin in his pocket next to a silver cross, which trapped the Devil in coin form. Jack made another deal, another promise extracted, another release.
When Jack eventually died, heaven turned him away. Too sinful. The Devil, bound by two separate agreements, refused to take him either. Jack was condemned to wander the darkness between the living world and the dead one, with nowhere to go and no light to see by. The Devil, in a moment of grudging mercy, tossed him a burning coal from the fires of hell. Jack put it in a carved-out turnip to keep it from burning out.
The Irish called the wandering light "Jack of the Lantern." Eventually just jack-o'-lantern.
The turnip lanterns in the window
Jack wasn't the only thing wandering during Samhain. The Celtic calendar marked October 31 as the boundary point between the warm season and the cold, between the world of the living and the world of the dead. On that night the boundary thinned. Spirits could cross. That included Stingy Jack. That included less comedic things.
One protection was light. Carved turnips with candles or coals inside them, placed in windows and doorways, served two purposes: they mimicked the wandering lanterns of spirits like Jack to confuse them, and they lit the threshold to show that the house was occupied by the living. They were not decorations. They were a practical measure against things you did not want inside.
Turnips were used because they were available, dense enough to carve, and small enough to hold a coal. The carved faces on surviving examples from Ireland look genuinely disturbing. The National Museum of Ireland has one on record from County Meath. The grain of the turnip is tighter than pumpkin, so the candlelight creates an intense, concentrated glow through the carved features. The effect is closer to a screaming skull than the grinning orange face you put on your porch. The original jack-o'-lantern was meant to frighten. It succeeded.
We went deep on Samhain and what the holiday was actually built around in the Halloween history post. The short version here: almost everything about October 31 in America comes from somewhere else, and the turnip lantern is one of the clearest examples.
The Irish brought it, the pumpkin stayed
The Great Famine began in Ireland in 1845 when a potato blight destroyed the primary food source of the rural poor. By 1852, approximately one million people had died of starvation and disease. Another million had emigrated. Over the following decades, another two to three million followed. The Irish arrived in America in enormous numbers, concentrated in cities like Boston, New York, and Philadelphia, and they brought their traditions with them.
The Samhain lantern tradition came too. But turnips in America were small and hard to find in the quantities needed for a widespread folk practice. Pumpkins were everywhere. Indigenous peoples had been cultivating them on this continent for at least 7,500 years before Europeans arrived. They were large, soft-fleshed, easy to hollow, easy to carve. A pumpkin could be gutted in minutes. A turnip took real effort.
The switch happened practically and gradually over the second half of the 1800s. The first written reference to pumpkin carving at Halloween in America appears in the 1860s. By the early 20th century the pumpkin was the standard. The turnip was forgotten. The tradition it carried was remembered without the object it arrived in.
What the pumpkin became
The pumpkin itself is native to North America. The word traces back through French "pompon" to the Greek "pepon," meaning large melon. The decorative Halloween pumpkin (perfectly round, vivid orange, symmetrical) is a product of agricultural breeding for appearance, not flavor. Most Halloween pumpkins taste terrible. They are grown to sit on porches, not to be eaten.
Americans now purchase approximately 1.3 billion pounds of pumpkins in the weeks surrounding Halloween each year. Most are not carved. Most of the ones that are carved are thrown away without anyone eating a single bite. Stingy Jack, who was banned from heaven for being too wasteful and sinful, would probably find this deeply satisfying.
The carved face in the window started as a warning to wandering spirits. It became a neighborhood decoration. It became a $600 million seasonal industry. It became a t-shirt. The full arc from Irish folk magic to American commercial Halloween is one of the stranger journeys any tradition has made. If you want to call yourself a pumpkin summoner, the tradition is genuinely old enough to take seriously.
The Pumpkin Summoner T-shirt is in the shop, along with the rest of the Halloween collection.
Murder Apparel is an independent, husband-and-wife brand making spooky, political gear for people who give a damn. We donate to fight injustice and support communities in need. 500,000+ weirdos on Instagram. Come find your people.
Frequently asked questions
Where did jack-o'-lanterns come from?
Jack-o'-lanterns originated in Irish folklore surrounding a character called Stingy Jack, a trickster who twice outsmarted the Devil and was barred from both heaven and hell after his death. Condemned to wander the dark between worlds with only a burning coal for light, he placed the coal in a carved turnip. Irish people began carving their own turnip lanterns during Samhain, the Celtic autumn festival marking the boundary between the living and the dead, to ward off Jack and other wandering spirits. The tradition was brought to America by Irish immigrants in the mid-1800s, where pumpkins replaced turnips as the carving vessel.
Who was Stingy Jack?
Stingy Jack is a figure from Irish folklore, a trickster who made two separate deals with the Devil to escape being taken to hell. In the first, he trapped the Devil in a tree by carving crosses into the bark and refused to let him down until the Devil promised never to claim his soul. In the second, he trapped the Devil in the form of a coin by keeping it next to a cross. When Jack died, heaven rejected him for being too sinful and the Devil, bound by his promises, refused to take him. Jack was condemned to wander the earth with only a burning coal in a carved turnip as a lamp. The Irish carved their own turnip lanterns to keep his wandering light away from their homes during Samhain.
Were jack-o'-lanterns originally carved from turnips?
Yes. The original jack-o'-lanterns in Ireland were carved from turnips, beets, and other root vegetables. Turnips were used because they were available, dense enough to hollow out, and small enough to contain a coal or candle. Surviving examples, including one in the collection of the National Museum of Ireland, show that turnip jack-o'-lanterns had a much more intense, unsettling appearance than pumpkin carvings: the tighter grain of the turnip creates a concentrated glow that makes the carved features look significantly more like a screaming skull. The pumpkin became the standard vessel only after Irish immigrants arrived in America and found pumpkins easier to carve and more widely available.
Why did the Irish carve jack-o'-lanterns?
The carved lanterns served as protection during Samhain, the Celtic festival on October 31 marking the thinning of the boundary between the world of the living and the world of the dead. When that boundary was thin, spirits including the wandering Stingy Jack could cross. Placing a lit carved lantern in a window or doorway was meant to ward off Jack and other spirits. The carved face mimicked the wandering lights associated with spirits, confusing them, and the lit threshold signaled that the home was occupied by the living. The lanterns were not decorations. They were a practical folk precaution against something people genuinely believed was moving through the dark.
Why are pumpkins used for Halloween in America?
Pumpkins replaced turnips because Irish immigrants arriving in America in the mid-1800s found them more practical. Turnips were small, hard to carve, and not widely available in the quantities needed. Pumpkins were native to North America, had been cultivated by Indigenous peoples for thousands of years, grew large, had soft flesh that hollowed easily, and could be carved in minutes. The switch happened gradually over the second half of the 1800s, and by the early 20th century the pumpkin had entirely replaced the turnip as the standard carving vessel for the tradition Irish immigrants had brought with them.
What is Samhain and how does it relate to Halloween?
Samhain was a Celtic festival marking the end of the harvest season and the beginning of winter, observed on the night of October 31 into November 1. The Celts believed the boundary between the world of the living and the world of the dead thinned on this night, allowing spirits to cross. Samhain involved bonfires, offerings, and practices meant to protect the living from wandering spirits. When Christianity spread through Ireland and Britain, the Church established All Saints' Day on November 1, followed by All Souls' Day on November 2, deliberately overlapping with existing pagan traditions. The evening before All Saints' Day became known as All Hallows' Eve, which became Halloween. Most of what Americans now associate with Halloween traces back through this chain to Samhain.
